Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#1 by colruddock , Tue May 06, 2014 11:39 am

My truck shat its pants this morning, came up with two fault codes;

P2148 - Fuel Injector Group A Supply Voltage Circuit High
U1120 - Network (seems to be a generic ECU fault)

Its a new shape Animal as per my signature.

Truck would run from anywhere between 2-30 seconds then cut out. No stutters, no misses, just cut out.

I've checked all the likely plugs on the engine bay and WD40'd them to expel any moisture that might have been lurking. Spotted that the Ralliart Injector Control Module box wasn't looking faulty but has evidence of corrosion on the casing screws. It was also hanging free as the sticky stuff that bonds it to the battery box had come off. This was my main suspect then.

I've removed the Ralliart loom, boxes and the vacuum pipe to the actuator (the one with the brass fitting in. I've replaced the vacuum pipe for a standard pipe.

The error P2148 has cleared and not returned after a couple of test drives. The U1120 hasn't cleared yet, but it might be a code the ECU self clears after 'x' number of succesful engine start/stop cycles.

The question I have though now is I'm still getting an overboost error flashing up P0234 - Turbo/Supercharger Overboost Condition, then the truck drops into limp mode.

I can't work out why, as far as the ECU is concerned it shouldn't know I had a ralliart box on. Is there something particular about the standard L200 actuator vac pipes? Has anyone any suggestions? Or can anyone take some pictures on or off the truck of their vac pipe so I can compare (its located under the airbox pipe to the turbo, small diameter, black rubber pipe and about 3" long if anyone can help but doesn't know where to find it)

I've just swapped it for a hose I had laying around (which is just the same as the ralliart effort, minus the inline brass fitting), so I can't see it being that unless theres something odd about the standard pipe


Ear all, see all, say nowt... Eyt all, sup all, pay nowt... And if ivver tha does owt fer nowt -Allus do it fer thissen


 
colruddock
Posts: 242
Date registered 03.27.2014


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#2 by colruddock , Tue May 06, 2014 4:50 pm

I'll become my own expert on this one then I think!

My best guess is that the daft ralliart box (with the restricted vacuum pipe and it's not particularly clever way of sitting between the ecu's standard signal to the injectors and boost pressure sensor) has been masking the fact Ive had overboosting issues on the turbo. So following its removal the trucks ecu can actually see what's going on and it's worried it.

After a bit of investigating, I can't move the rod on the actuator at all, I'll find out this weekend if that's the actuator that's gone tits up, or the vnt on the turbo being bunged up by the stupid egr. My money's on the turbo being coked up from the pointless recirculating of exhaust gasses.

I checked the pressure pipe from the pressure sensor back to the inlet and that's clear, so there's one less suspect.

Can anyone tell me what to order for an egr blanking kit for a new shape? Is the kit the same as the classics? And what pipes do I need to order after the egr coolers taken off?
That might not be a task for this weekend, but it's coming off soon regardless.


Ear all, see all, say nowt... Eyt all, sup all, pay nowt... And if ivver tha does owt fer nowt -Allus do it fer thissen


 
colruddock
Posts: 242
Date registered 03.27.2014


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#3 by colruddock , Wed May 07, 2014 9:39 am

This topics proving to be about as popular as a dose of the clap!

Final try then, can anyone tell me what a standard new shape turbo boost pressure should be?
Once I've stripped and cleaned the turbo this weekend I'll take it on another run and ideally would like to know what the boost pressure should show.

From yesterdays test run with the software logging (ignore the 'Golf 1.9tdi' reference, I've just not bothered to create a new profile yet), right before it dropped into limp mode and threw up the overboost error it peaked at 22.48psi.


Ear all, see all, say nowt... Eyt all, sup all, pay nowt... And if ivver tha does owt fer nowt -Allus do it fer thissen


 
colruddock
Posts: 242
Date registered 03.27.2014


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#4 by WelshMart , Wed May 07, 2014 11:25 am

There seems to be very little information around about these Ralliart boxes. The P2148 code apparently is due to faulty loom in the module, this is what mine throws up with a similar fault, will start up sometimes and die quickly. I'm not in the truck today, but tomorrow I can log boost pressure for you using my app if this helps.


2006 4 Work, 285/75/16 Khumo MTs, 2.5 inch wide flexiflares, 4mm steel skid plates, Snorkel, CB Radio, Rallitronic module, broken Leer canopy, LED work light, LED bed light, 20" LED flood light, McK Rock Sliders, Team Heko wind deflectors, 2" suspension lift, Reverse Camera


 
WelshMart
Posts: 593
Date registered 02.19.2013


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#5 by colruddock , Wed May 07, 2014 11:47 am

Quote: WelshMart wrote in post #4
There seems to be very little information around about these Ralliart boxes. The P2148 code apparently is due to faulty loom in the module, this is what mine throws up with a similar fault, will start up sometimes and die quickly. I'm not in the truck today, but tomorrow I can log boost pressure for you using my app if this helps.


Yeah that'd be grand, thanks. Just so I have some piece of mind that when I have it back running right the boost pressure is at or below a known norm.

If you're still running the Ralliart box, I'll expect my results to be a bit lower.

The Ralliart loom and module itself looks fine, but there's something not quite right in the injector control module box, so I think that's where my issue was. Without taking the box apart I won't know though, so that job can tag on the end of my ever increasing list of things to do.

If I can prove its that that was faulty, I can at least sell the rest of the Ralliart setup as spares for someone else.


Ear all, see all, say nowt... Eyt all, sup all, pay nowt... And if ivver tha does owt fer nowt -Allus do it fer thissen


 
colruddock
Posts: 242
Date registered 03.27.2014


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#6 by woody13 , Wed May 07, 2014 1:03 pm

Don't worry about the lack of replys Col,this makes you our Ralliart specialist.When ya get it sorted you will be the go-to fella on this subject....


FORUM AREA REPRESENTATIVE - North West England
2.8 Import,gone but not forgotten...
The Beast,never to be forgotten...
The Big Silver Beastie,soon to be reborn...

The Frankenfender is on its way....


 
woody13
Forum Legend
Posts: 12.549
Date registered 10.05.2011


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#7 by colruddock , Wed May 07, 2014 1:31 pm

Quote: woody13 wrote in post #6
Don't worry about the lack of replys Col,this makes you our Ralliart specialist.When ya get it sorted you will be the go-to fella on this subject....


Haha, and my go-to response to any enquiry will be 'remove it!'


Ear all, see all, say nowt... Eyt all, sup all, pay nowt... And if ivver tha does owt fer nowt -Allus do it fer thissen


 
colruddock
Posts: 242
Date registered 03.27.2014


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#8 by woody13 , Wed May 07, 2014 1:33 pm

Short n sweet...


FORUM AREA REPRESENTATIVE - North West England
2.8 Import,gone but not forgotten...
The Beast,never to be forgotten...
The Big Silver Beastie,soon to be reborn...

The Frankenfender is on its way....


 
woody13
Forum Legend
Posts: 12.549
Date registered 10.05.2011


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#9 by marcosuk , Wed May 07, 2014 5:00 pm

My Animal with everything standard is running max 20 psi boost altho, sometimes it will briefly hit 21 if giving it some beans! I have blanked my Egr off at the exhaust side of the egr cooler with no issues to date.


....2006 Newshape Animal, 3 Piece Tonneau lid, Cooper Discoverer STT, LezT Lift Shackles, Reverse Camera, Boost Gauge, Blanked EGR, Cobra Bullbar, Rear Bar, Smoked Tail-lights, L.E.D's throughout, Parrott Handsfree, K&N Filter, Silicone Hoses, Oil Catch Can, De-Cat, MCK Rock Sliders....


 
marcosuk
Posts: 816
Date registered 01.03.2013


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#10 by colruddock , Wed May 07, 2014 5:17 pm

Quote: marcosuk wrote in post #9
My Animal with everything standard is running max 20 psi boost altho, sometimes it will briefly hit 21 if giving it some beans! I have blanked my Egr off at the exhaust side of the egr cooler with no issues to date.


Cheers.... and that's still with the Ralliart box fitted I'm assuming. Also with the EGR being blanked (is it still physically there, the valve, and plugged in?), does it not throw up an error code that needs mapping out?
With my previous experience of VAG diesels, the EGR was monitored by the ECU on cars made after about 2003. So it threw up a low EGR flow error that needed to be mapped out by a tuner.

Roll on Saturday, I've got my Mr Muscle oven cleaner at the ready, and I'm dousing all the turbo's nuts and bolts I can see daily with WD40. Hopefully I can get it off fairly pain free.


Ear all, see all, say nowt... Eyt all, sup all, pay nowt... And if ivver tha does owt fer nowt -Allus do it fer thissen


 
colruddock
Posts: 242
Date registered 03.27.2014


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#11 by marcosuk , Wed May 07, 2014 5:31 pm

Box & bleed valve to the actuator still fitted.. EGR Valve still there plugged in.. No codes... I should point out tho, i never had any codes before i done the egr blank, so this might not solve your problem?


....2006 Newshape Animal, 3 Piece Tonneau lid, Cooper Discoverer STT, LezT Lift Shackles, Reverse Camera, Boost Gauge, Blanked EGR, Cobra Bullbar, Rear Bar, Smoked Tail-lights, L.E.D's throughout, Parrott Handsfree, K&N Filter, Silicone Hoses, Oil Catch Can, De-Cat, MCK Rock Sliders....


 
marcosuk
Posts: 816
Date registered 01.03.2013


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#12 by colruddock , Wed May 07, 2014 5:37 pm

Quote: marcosuk wrote in post #11
Box & bleed valve to the actuator still fitted.. EGR Valve still there plugged in.. No codes... I should point out tho, i never had any codes before i done the egr blank, so this might not solve your problem?


No I don't expect it will, the EGR removal is more of a preventative maintenance thing for once I've cleaned the gizzards of the turbo.

I'm blaming the EGR for me not being able to move the actuator rod. The thinking being the variable vanes are carboned up from the recycled gasses, preventing them from altering their pitch, and therefore giving me too much boost at higher RPM and throttle openings.

It may turn out to be something totally different, but that's my thinking so far.


Ear all, see all, say nowt... Eyt all, sup all, pay nowt... And if ivver tha does owt fer nowt -Allus do it fer thissen


 
colruddock
Posts: 242
Date registered 03.27.2014


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#13 by marcosuk , Wed May 07, 2014 5:46 pm

Just blank the egr then at the exhaust side before it enters the cooler, that way your not letting hot gasses eat away at it...Saves having to remove it completely...

I also fitted an oil catch can to stop oil vapours entering the turbo, so that could also be an option for you??


....2006 Newshape Animal, 3 Piece Tonneau lid, Cooper Discoverer STT, LezT Lift Shackles, Reverse Camera, Boost Gauge, Blanked EGR, Cobra Bullbar, Rear Bar, Smoked Tail-lights, L.E.D's throughout, Parrott Handsfree, K&N Filter, Silicone Hoses, Oil Catch Can, De-Cat, MCK Rock Sliders....


 
marcosuk
Posts: 816
Date registered 01.03.2013


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#14 by colruddock , Wed May 07, 2014 5:48 pm

Quote: marcosuk wrote in post #13
Just blank the egr then at the exhaust side before it enters the cooler, that way your not letting hot gasses eat away at it...Saves having to remove it completely...

I also fitted an oil catch can to stop oil vapours entering the turbo, so that could also be an option for you??


You got any pics of the catch can install? I'm all about the preventative maintenance at the minute!


Ear all, see all, say nowt... Eyt all, sup all, pay nowt... And if ivver tha does owt fer nowt -Allus do it fer thissen


 
colruddock
Posts: 242
Date registered 03.27.2014


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#15 by marcosuk , Wed May 07, 2014 6:00 pm

Just a couple.. I used fuel hose..
Bild entfernt (keine Rechte)
Bild entfernt (keine Rechte)


....2006 Newshape Animal, 3 Piece Tonneau lid, Cooper Discoverer STT, LezT Lift Shackles, Reverse Camera, Boost Gauge, Blanked EGR, Cobra Bullbar, Rear Bar, Smoked Tail-lights, L.E.D's throughout, Parrott Handsfree, K&N Filter, Silicone Hoses, Oil Catch Can, De-Cat, MCK Rock Sliders....


 
marcosuk
Posts: 816
Date registered 01.03.2013


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#16 by colruddock , Wed May 07, 2014 6:20 pm

Grand, cheers


Ear all, see all, say nowt... Eyt all, sup all, pay nowt... And if ivver tha does owt fer nowt -Allus do it fer thissen


 
colruddock
Posts: 242
Date registered 03.27.2014


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#17 by marcosuk , Wed May 07, 2014 6:23 pm

No probs mate... Hope you get it sorted


....2006 Newshape Animal, 3 Piece Tonneau lid, Cooper Discoverer STT, LezT Lift Shackles, Reverse Camera, Boost Gauge, Blanked EGR, Cobra Bullbar, Rear Bar, Smoked Tail-lights, L.E.D's throughout, Parrott Handsfree, K&N Filter, Silicone Hoses, Oil Catch Can, De-Cat, MCK Rock Sliders....


 
marcosuk
Posts: 816
Date registered 01.03.2013


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#18 by WelshMart , Thu May 08, 2014 8:05 am

Monitored boost for you this morning and I'm getting max of 19.3psi, this is without any ralliart box fitted.

@Marcosuk how did you go about blanking the egr?


2006 4 Work, 285/75/16 Khumo MTs, 2.5 inch wide flexiflares, 4mm steel skid plates, Snorkel, CB Radio, Rallitronic module, broken Leer canopy, LED work light, LED bed light, 20" LED flood light, McK Rock Sliders, Team Heko wind deflectors, 2" suspension lift, Reverse Camera


 
WelshMart
Posts: 593
Date registered 02.19.2013


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#19 by colruddock , Thu May 08, 2014 12:28 pm

Thanks, I'll keep that figure in mind for once its built back up.

I was worried that it was hugely overboosting at 22.5, but a little over 3psi before it cottons on and steps in with limp home mode is less concerning.


Ear all, see all, say nowt... Eyt all, sup all, pay nowt... And if ivver tha does owt fer nowt -Allus do it fer thissen


 
colruddock
Posts: 242
Date registered 03.27.2014


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#20 by marcosuk , Thu May 08, 2014 6:38 pm

Take the gasket out, then use that to make a template on some sheet metal.. The gasket is between the pipe & the cooler.. I blanked the exhaust side NOT the egr side of the cooler


....2006 Newshape Animal, 3 Piece Tonneau lid, Cooper Discoverer STT, LezT Lift Shackles, Reverse Camera, Boost Gauge, Blanked EGR, Cobra Bullbar, Rear Bar, Smoked Tail-lights, L.E.D's throughout, Parrott Handsfree, K&N Filter, Silicone Hoses, Oil Catch Can, De-Cat, MCK Rock Sliders....


 
marcosuk
Posts: 816
Date registered 01.03.2013


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#21 by Basil , Fri May 09, 2014 6:54 am

Colin, I have an answer for you, but my Internet is crap until saturday, it's an ecu code issue that is covered by the manual we have here. I'll get the text up on Saturday.

Basil


2007, Y plate 4life,
2010, 55 plate L200 4work++
March 2013, 11 plate Barbarian. Wrapped, OME all round, remapped to 210, straight piped 2.5" SS.


 
Basil
Forum Legend
Posts: 12.392
Date registered 03.07.2012


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#22 by colruddock , Fri May 09, 2014 9:23 am

Quote: Basil wrote in post #21
Colin, I have an answer for you, but my Internet is crap until saturday, it's an ecu code issue that is covered by the manual we have here. I'll get the text up on Saturday.

Basil


Cheers @basil I'll keep an eye on this thread then while I make a start on it.

Still need to at least take the actuator off and test it with my hand vac pump. Just to see which is causing the rod not to move, turbo or actuator.


Ear all, see all, say nowt... Eyt all, sup all, pay nowt... And if ivver tha does owt fer nowt -Allus do it fer thissen


 
colruddock
Posts: 242
Date registered 03.27.2014


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#23 by colruddock , Sun May 11, 2014 8:24 pm

So, the turbo's been off. It put up a sterling effort in remaining on the motor, but in the end I won. The main issue was the actuator has a pin that goes through the arm on the turbo, this has seized into the turbos arm and also the turbos arm had seized. As suspected the ralliart upgrade had been masking this fault for some time....

So with the turbo off two more lessons were learned;

First, the actuator works on pressure rather than vacuum to operate.

Second, that the turbo has a traditional style wastegate to control the boost pressure, and not a variable pitch vane setup (definitely easier to service)

Here's pics of the turbo off the truck after a light service to get the wastegate functioning...


Closed


Open


Wide open (exhaust port visible)



Big hole once you get the airbox turbo and cat out of the way (new stud visible in the manifold, after the old one sheared)!


Ear all, see all, say nowt... Eyt all, sup all, pay nowt... And if ivver tha does owt fer nowt -Allus do it fer thissen


 
colruddock
Posts: 242
Date registered 03.27.2014


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#24 by birdie , Sun May 11, 2014 8:28 pm

How is it running now then?


NO MORE L200, TIME FOR A MANS VEHICLE!!!!!


 
birdie
Posts: 4.873
Date registered 11.06.2012


RE: Removed Ralliart Power Upgrade, Still Some Issues

#25 by colruddock , Sun May 11, 2014 8:45 pm

Pretty well, I've done about 40 trouble free miles after finishing rebuilding it this morning. It's a fair bit slower, boost levels spike at 15.5 and holds at about 14.5psi. Thats a fair bit lower than Welshmarts without the animal upgrade, but as far as I can tell everything is operating fine.

If it was a 160ish bhp truck before, it does feel to have dropped to a 130ish bhp truck now.

I'm pretty sure all the codes created within this thread are now sorted for good. I'll just keep my eye out for the gearbox ones returning now in the other thread, as I inherently distrust electrical issues more than mechanical ones!


Ear all, see all, say nowt... Eyt all, sup all, pay nowt... And if ivver tha does owt fer nowt -Allus do it fer thissen


 
colruddock
Posts: 242
Date registered 03.27.2014


   

Sidney Powell responds after Trump campaign says she is not part of legal team:
WINDOW STICKING

Xobor Create your own Forum with Xobor